Sheri finds a rule for the Tower Puzzle & Nanako finds a rule for the Peg Game/chapter 6

9/20/00  Many sessions before this day, Sheri had worked on the Tower Puzzle (see ch. 6). The object is to move the tower of discs from one peg to another. The rules are: you can't put a bigger disc on top of a smaller one, you can only move one disc at a time, and later you will need to move the discs in the minimum # of moves. Don starts young people off with maybe only 3 discs. Then lets the student start with more.

On this day, Sheri figured out the rule for the Tower Puzzle; her work is shown below:

In the process she found patterns in the table of values- the differences go up 2, 4, 8, 16, 32.. Don reminded her about writing numbers like these as powers of 2- see her work on the right above. The y-numbers she noticed were 1 less than these powers of 2.  Don wrote 7 as 23  - 1, then Sheri wrote the others this way and wrote the rule as 2x - 1= y. Don asked Sheri to graph the rule and graph negative values of x. In the process Sheri got into negative exponents and statements like 1/4 - 1 = - 3/4, which they talked about. See her work above. Her graph (an exponential function) is shown below:

One student said the curve approaches y = -1, and is called the asymptote.

On 9/21, Don asked Sheri to write about what she did the day before with the Tower Puzzle. As can often be the case, students put away their work and forget about it. Don asked her this, explaining that the reason he asked was to make sure she understood and could explain what she did. She started to do this and when Don saw her slowing down, he changed the subject. He suggested she finish at home. (Sheri hasn't finished this yet, as of 11/2/00.. it's difficult to get young people to write down things like this. Don will persist!)

One day Don, a student and her father, brought  to a welder the 2D graph she did of The Tower Puzzle. He made the 3D rotation of that curve 2x - 1=y with stiff wire, below. Don hangs it in his Math room; in 25 years it has only had to be repaired once!

Don had Sheri as a 4-6th grader, then she went to University High School. She came back as almost a 12th grader, to prepare for Calculus. Don worked with her for about 3 hrs. individually over the last month. Today, a week into her calculus class, she told me "What we did the last 3 weeks (derivatives), the teacher did with my class in one day, and I was like the only one in the class that understood what she was talking about! It really helped for me to talk with you about the problems as I worked on them".

It's been a pleasure working with you Sheri, as well as your sister, your mother, 2 aunts, and 2 cousins over the years- what a wonderful family!

Nanako played with the Peg game (see chapter 6)

The object of this puzzle is to interchange the blue and the red pegs. The rules are 1) you can move to a hole that's next to a peg; 2) you can jump, but only one peg and it must be of the other color, and 3) you can't move backwards. You must start with the empty space in the middle and end that way. You can use golf tees, as I do, or you can use two different kinds of coins or bottle caps or pieces of colored paper as the pieces.

It takes time for people to figure out the pattern of how the pieces move, without having to start over. She was able to do this fairly quickly. Then Don made a table below, where x was the number of pairs of pegs, and y was the number of moves to interchange the pegs. She started with one pair, and it took 3 moves, starting with 2 pairs, took 8 moves.

Nanako saw the pattern 1x3=3, 2x4=8, 3x5=15.. could be written as 1(1+2)=3 and 2(2+2)=8 and 3(3+2)=15..
Nanako found the rule x*(x+2)=y with some help from Don. In the process Don made sure she could
multiply negative and positive numbers with the pattern (see above at the bottom of the page in the center). She then graphed this function to get a parabola.

They talked about the graph having symmetry and the axis of symmetry was x = -1.

A teacher at one of Don's workshops found a pattern that the hole makes as the pegs are moved-very interesting!

Don never saw anything like this.

Besides the Peg Game and The Tower Puzzle, Don also has in his Mathroom (see 5 views) :

The Chinese Ring Puzzle, given to Don by Ian who made it in his Calculus class (no one has figured out a rule for this puzzle, but Don and AnnEmily have done this blindfolded)

A 6-piece burr puzzle, given to Don by a student whose grandfather made it:

The 15 puzzle (magic square- each row, column and the 2 main diagonals have to add to 15),

Tangrams (an old Elementary Science Study McGraw-Hill publication), as well as a few metal Tavern Puzzles from Tucker-Jones House, Inc., Cuisenaire Rods (see Genny's dog and Sheri's ratio of Vol of Pyramid/Vol of cube), Kaleidocycles (M.C. Escher) to put together, 1x1x1cm cubes to build the Soma pieces, Pattern Blocks, Geostrips, Geoblocks, a scale (in kg-surprises everyone), a balance scale with 10 gm weights, Nautilus shell-full and 1/2, other shells, protractor, compasses, + and an oscilloscope and oscillator.

Jonathan, a 9th grader then, views sine waves and Lissajous figures on the oscilloscope with the help of an oscillator (on the left).

Jonathan graphs y=sin x, then finds the equation which (a) doubles the height, (b) has twice as many waves and (c) shifts the sine wave 60 degrees to the right.

Jonathan combines cos x and sin x at right angles. The resultant Lissajous figure is in the upper left hand corner is a circle.

Jonathan combines sin x and sin 2x at right angles.

Jonathan combines sin x and sin 3x at right angles.

After doing these, Jonathan worked with a complex sand pendulum which made Lissajous figures by dropping sand on a piece of paper. The he proceeded to get the same figures by using parametric equations in Mathematica!

Jonathan's Mom said Don was his hero. He was ready to drop out of high school, and after working on math with Don, he ended up doing well in mathematics, graduating, got married, and works on computers while attending college. And most exciting, Jonathan has become Don's hero, because he has helped fix Mrs. Cohen's and Don's computers AND he is now making Don's A Map to Calculus you are looking at, show Don's sample problems and student discoveries - at a click! Thank you Jonathan!!!

Ian made this graph of sin 2x vs sin x at right angles by hand, then Don added the colors to show where the points came from (up from the sinx graph, and left from the sin2x- in this order- 0o orange x 1, 30o red x 2, 45o green x 3, then 90o blue x 4. These points only make the upper half of the bow-tie on the right side.

.

See Puzzles, Old & New, how to make and solve them, by Jerry Slocum & Jack Botermans, distributed by the University of Washington Press, Seattle

To other discoveries
To order Don's materials
Mathman home